Final IFComp scores
Oct. 31st, 2018 11:05 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
kjorteoSo now that I've played five six games for IFComp, it's time to submit my scores! The feedback and review are just going to be edited versions of the posts I already wrote out here. All that's left are the number scores.
In order of my personal most to least favorite:
(Links all lead to my Dreamwidth writeups of each game)
Animalia by Ian Michael Waddell:9 101
Basilica de Sangre by Bitter Karella: 9
Re: Dragon by Jack Welch: 8
Haywire by Peregrine Wade: 7
Let's Explore Geography! Canadian Commodities Trader Simulation Exercise by Carter Sande: 6
Instruction Set by Jared Jackson: 4
Huge thanks toxyzzysqrl for getting us all hooked on IF. If they keep the "literally anyone can be a judge; just play and rate at least five" rule, I might just do this again next year. It was fun! I got to play some neat games. Also thanks to swordianmaster for doing five other games, so between all of us we have a pretty good spread here. Go check their scores out (Xyzzy, Sword) and maybe try some of these yourself. Otherwise, let's do this again next time, yeah?
1 I gave Animalia a score of 9 when we played it back in 2018, both here and in the official slate of scores we submitted to IFComp for that year. Since then, though, I've changed my mind and decided that Animalia should be a perfect 10, and so we're sort of unofficially de facto treating it as one in hindsight. This is, to date and as of this writing when we're making this edit, the first and so far only time we've ever changed or wish we could change an IFComp score in retrospect.
In order of my personal most to least favorite:
(Links all lead to my Dreamwidth writeups of each game)
Animalia by Ian Michael Waddell:
Basilica de Sangre by Bitter Karella: 9
Re: Dragon by Jack Welch: 8
Haywire by Peregrine Wade: 7
Let's Explore Geography! Canadian Commodities Trader Simulation Exercise by Carter Sande: 6
Instruction Set by Jared Jackson: 4
Huge thanks to
xyzzysqrl for getting us all hooked on IF. If they keep the "literally anyone can be a judge; just play and rate at least five" rule, I might just do this again next year. It was fun! I got to play some neat games. Also thanks to swordianmaster for doing five other games, so between all of us we have a pretty good spread here. Go check their scores out (Xyzzy, Sword) and maybe try some of these yourself. Otherwise, let's do this again next time, yeah?1 I gave Animalia a score of 9 when we played it back in 2018, both here and in the official slate of scores we submitted to IFComp for that year. Since then, though, I've changed my mind and decided that Animalia should be a perfect 10, and so we're sort of unofficially de facto treating it as one in hindsight. This is, to date and as of this writing when we're making this edit, the first and so far only time we've ever changed or wish we could change an IFComp score in retrospect.